Law of Attraction vs Law of Assumption, Explained Honestly
The law of attraction is the belief that your thoughts and feelings draw matching events into your life, so "like attracts like." The law of assumption, taught by Neville Goddard, says something narrower: assume the feeling that your wish is already fulfilled, persist in that assumption, and reality will come to reflect it. Neither has scientific support as a physical law, though parts of both overlap with real psychology.
Where does the law of attraction come from?
The law of attraction grew out of New Thought, a nineteenth-century American movement which held that the mind shapes health and circumstance. Its usual founding figure is Phineas Quimby, a New England clockmaker who became interested in mind and body after noticing that excitement eased his own symptoms of illness. Quimby himself never used the phrase.
The words appeared in print in 1855, in a book by the Spiritualist writer Andrew Jackson Davis, and were developed as a general principle by Prentice Mulford in the 1880s. In 1906 William Walker Atkinson published Thought Vibration or the Law of Attraction in the Thought World, which states the idea plainly: like attracts like, and the thoughts we hold send out vibrations that draw similar things to us.
The modern revival came in 2006 with The Secret, a film and then a book by Rhonda Byrne. It taught readers to think about what they want with as much feeling as possible, and it turned the law of attraction into a household phrase.
What is the law of assumption?
The law of assumption is the name now given to the teaching of Neville Goddard (1905–1972), a lecturer born in Barbados who settled in New York and taught there and in California from the late 1930s until his death. His short 1944 book Feeling Is the Secret sets out the core idea.
"Realization of your wish is accomplished by assuming the feeling of the wish fulfilled." (Neville Goddard, Feeling Is the Secret, 1944)
Followers often summarise this as "living in the end": you imagine a short scene that would only happen once the wish is true, feel it as real, and then behave as the person for whom it is already done. Neville recommended doing this in a drowsy state close to sleep, which his readers now call SATS, the "state akin to sleep." He also read the Bible as a psychological drama about consciousness rather than as history.
In recent years his recorded lectures and books have been widely shared online, where the law of assumption is often presented as the more precise, more inward cousin of the law of attraction.
How is the law of assumption different from the law of attraction?
The short answer: the law of attraction talks about attracting things from outside, while the law of assumption says there is nothing outside to attract from, only your own state of consciousness. In practice they share many methods, but the emphasis differs.
| Law of attraction | Law of assumption | |
|---|---|---|
| Main source | New Thought writers; Atkinson (1906); The Secret (2006) | Neville Goddard's books and lectures, from 1938 to 1972 |
| Core claim | Thoughts and feelings send out a "vibration" that draws matching events | Persistently assuming the wish is fulfilled shapes what you experience |
| Key metaphor | A magnet, or a radio frequency | A play in which you choose your role |
| Typical practice | Positive thinking, affirmations, vision boards, gratitude | Imagining a scene of the fulfilled wish, often near sleep; "living in the end" |
| Attitude to doubt | Negative thoughts may attract negative events | What counts is the assumption you persist in |
| Role of other people | Others are part of the outside world you attract | Others reflect your assumption about them |
| Language | Universe, energy, vibration | Consciousness, imagination, state |
If you want to try a grounded version of either, our guide on how to manifest by writing walks through a calm method that ends with a concrete step.
Is there scientific evidence for the law of attraction?
No. There is no evidence that thoughts send out a force that pulls events, people or money toward you, and the claim is framed in a way that cannot easily be tested. Physicists have criticised the borrowing of words like "quantum" and "frequency," and skeptic writers reviewing The Secret in 2007 concluded that neither the film nor the book has any basis in scientific reality.
Nobody has measured a "vibration" of thought acting on the world. When something good follows a hopeful thought, it is easy to remember the match and forget the many hopeful thoughts that led nowhere.
So why do so many people say it works for them?
Because several real, well-studied processes sit inside these practices, even if the explanation offered for them is different.
- Attention. Once a goal is clear, you notice relevant chances you would have missed: a job listing, a conversation, a free evening.
- Self-efficacy. Albert Bandura showed that believing you can carry out a task affects whether you start it and how long you persist. Assuming "I am someone who already did this" can nudge that belief.
- Expectations. Gabriele Oettingen and Doris Mayer found that people who judged a good outcome as likely put in more effort and did better over the following months.
- Specific plans. If-then plans about when and where to act have a medium-to-large effect on reaching goals across 94 tests in a 2006 meta-analysis (d = .65).
- Calm. A quiet ritual before sleep, done kindly, can lower worry and help you think straight the next day.
None of these require a cosmic law. They do suggest why sincere practitioners often feel more capable and notice more openings.
What are the risks of believing in manifestation?
The main risks are blame, pressure and skipped action. A 2023 study by Lucas Dixon, Matthew Hornsey and Nicole Hartley, with 1,023 participants across three studies, found that over a third endorsed manifestation beliefs. Those who scored higher saw themselves as more successful and expected more success, but they were also more drawn to risky investments, more likely to have experienced bankruptcy, and more likely to believe they could reach unlikely success quickly.
Other risks are easier to see from the inside:
- Victim-blaming. If thoughts create reality, illness, poverty or loss can start to look like a personal failure of mindset. That is unkind and untrue.
- Toxic positivity. Pushing away sadness or doubt because it might "attract" bad things leaves real feelings unprocessed.
- Magical thinking in place of help. Imagining recovery is not a substitute for a doctor, and assuming money is coming is not a budget.
- Less effort, not more. Oettingen's research suggests that pleasant fantasies of the end result, on their own, can lower the energy you bring to reaching it.
How can you practise either one more wisely?
Keep the parts that help and drop the parts that harm. A few suggestions from the evidence:
- Write the wish down in one clear sentence, so you know what you want.
- Imagine the fulfilled moment, briefly and warmly, if it calms you.
- Then name the main obstacle, especially the inner one, and write an if-then plan for it.
- Take one small step today. Repeat tomorrow.
- When something goes wrong, don't treat it as proof that you thought badly. Treat it as information.
This is close to what people have done for a very long time: name a hope, set it somewhere visible, and get on with the day. You can see older versions of the same impulse in wish tree traditions around the world, and a modern one in a 2027 vision board. In Treeora, each wish is written by hand and carries one small step for today on its back, a way of honouring the hope while keeping your feet on the ground.
Which one should you choose?
Choose the language that feels most honest to you, and hold it lightly. If the idea of a universe responding gives you comfort, that is your business. If Neville's inward framing makes more sense, that is fine too. What the research supports is the same either way: clarity about what you want, a realistic look at what stands in the way, and small actions you actually take. The rest is belief, and belief is allowed to stay personal.
Sources
- Law of attraction (New Thought). Wikipedia)
- New Thought. Wikipedia
- Phineas Quimby. Wikipedia
- The Secret (Byrne book). Wikipedia)
- Neville Goddard. Wikipedia
- Goddard, N. (1944). Feeling Is the Secret. Internet Archive
- Dixon, L. J., Hornsey, M. J., & Hartley, N. (2023). "The Secret" to success? The psychology of belief in manifestation. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin
- Bandura, A. (1977). Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. Psychological Review, 84(2), 191–215
- Oettingen, G., & Mayer, D. (2002). The motivating function of thinking about the future: Expectations versus fantasies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 83(5), 1198–1212
- Gollwitzer, P. M., & Sheeran, P. (2006). Implementation intentions and goal achievement: A meta-analysis of effects and processes. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 38, 69–11938002-1)
- Kappes, H. B., & Oettingen, G. (2011). Positive fantasies about idealized futures sap energy. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 47(4), 719–729